Supreme Court’s dismissal of PIL on Covid vaccine safety is counter to known science and mathematics

By Bhaskaran Raman*
On 14 Oct 2024, the Supreme Court of India dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) on the side-effects of the Covid vaccine. In 2021, the world saw the rollout of various Covid vaccine candidates. In India, Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin and Serum Institute of India’s Covishield were rolled out. Covishield was nothing but Oxford’s AstraZeneca relabelled in India.

The importance of open-minded and scientific probe of Covid vaccine safety

In 2020/2021, all Covid vaccines were authorized for emergency use, which meant that the necessary efficacy and safety follow-up was incomplete at that time. The originally approved trials – called randomised controlled trials (RCT) had a “vaccine” group and a “placebo” group for comparison. Such experimental comparison/control is the cornerstone of the scientific method – which even children learn in photosynthesis experiments in class-1. The vaccine trials were scheduled to conclude in late 2022/early 2023. For instance, Covaxin’s trial was scheduled to end in Dec 2022, while Covishield’s trial was scheduled to end in Feb 2023.
In another court case, the government has argued that safety is not of concern now that “Covid is long gone. Vaccination is long over”. Nothing could be further from the truth. The long-term comparison of the two groups “vaccine” versus “placebo” is absolutely essential for answering with confidence, questions such as: “are the increased heart attacks among youth today due to the Covid vaccine or some other reason?” However, none of Covid vaccines (including Covaxin & Covishield) which were originally approved for emergency use, have completed trial results.
The issue of long-term safety is all the more important given that 100+ crore Indians, including tens of crores of children and youth have been administered the emergency use products, although nowhere in the world did children and youth face an emergency due to Covid itself – they were hardly affected by the virus.
Despite the monumental importance however, the Supreme Court gave this issue only a brief few moments before dismissing the PIL without even a hearing. Furthermore, the remarks made by the bench prior to the dismissal are counter to known science and mathematics.

Remarks counter to known science

The bench has remarked “Because of the vaccines, we were able to deal with the pandemic”. Now, the known science behind immunology, which is indeed the basis of vaccines, is that exposure to a virus (weakened in a vaccine or natural) builds robust immunity. As of July 2021, we knew that the majority of Indians had already been exposed to the virus naturally, while only 10% of Indians had been given the vaccines at that time. Therefore the claim of vaccines helping in dealing with the pandemic is counter to known science.
The claim also flies in the face of data from other countries which had wave-after-wave of Covid even after much higher coverage of Covid vaccines. Two stark examples are that of Singapore and Australia, which had no major Covid waves at all, until after 75% of their population had been vaccinated – see graph of data below. More worryingly, both Singapore and Australia have reported record levels of excess deaths in the years following mass Covid vaccination.

The renowned physicist and Nobel Prize winner Richard Feynman once said: “It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” The theory of the Indian Supreme Court that the Covid vaccines helped deal with the pandemic may be beautiful and emotionally satisfying, but it does not match with observed data, and hence it is scientifically flawed.

Remarks counter to known mathematics

During the brief proceedings, the bench also checked if the counsel of the petitioner had any Covid vaccine side-effect. When the counsel said that he had not had any side-effect (thankfully), the bench immediately dismissed the case. This reflects a flawed understanding of basic mathematical probability. If the counsel of the petitioner was not affected, it clearly does not mean that the risk of the vaccine side-effect was zero. As an analogy, if a particular smoker does not get lung cancer (thankfully), it does not mean that there is no risk of smoking.
In dismissing the case without even a hearing, the Supreme Court has overestimated the risk of Covid and underestimated the risk of the vaccine. What is the relative risk of death or serious health damage with versus without the vaccine? It is precisely to answer this question that the vaccine trials are conducted. Surely, the Supreme Court is not expected to know such risk-benefit analysis. However, it is expected to know enough to seek expert opinion and ask for the trial results.

The way forward

The dismissal of the PIL by the Supreme Court is thus on flawed grounds. To repeat, none of the Covid vaccines which were originally approved for emergency use, have completed trial results. The Supreme Court should therefore do the right thing and ask the relevant authorities such as the ICMR and the vaccine manufacturers for the completed trial results.
---
*Professor at IIT Bombay. Views are personal

Comments

Loktantra Bachao Abhiyan raises concerns over Jharkhand Adivasis' plight in Assam, BJP policies

By Our Representative The Loktantra Bachao Abhiyan (Save Democracy Campaign) has issued a pressing call to protect Adivasi rights in Jharkhand, highlighting serious concerns over the treatment of Jharkhandi Adivasis in Assam. During a press conference in Ranchi on November 9, representatives from Assam, Chhattisgarh, and Madhya Pradesh criticized the current approach of BJP-led governments in these states, arguing it has exacerbated Adivasi struggles for rights, land, and cultural preservation.

Promoting love or instilling hate and fear: Why is RSS seeking a meeting with Rahul Gandhi?

By Ram Puniyani* India's anti-colonial struggle was marked by a diverse range of social movements, one of the most significant being Hindu-Muslim unity and the emergence of a unified Indian identity among people of all religions. The nationalist, anti-colonial movement championed this unity, best embodied by Mahatma Gandhi, who ultimately gave his life for this cause. Gandhi once wrote, “The union that we want is not a patched-up thing but a union of hearts... Swaraj (self-rule) for India must be an impossible dream without an indissoluble union between the Hindus and Muslims of India. It must not be a mere truce... It must be a partnership between equals, each respecting the religion of the other.”

Right-arm fast bowler who helped West Indies shape arguably greatest Test team in cricket history

By Harsh Thakor* Malcolm Marshall redefined what it meant to be a right-arm fast bowler, challenging the traditional laws of biomechanics with his unique skill. As we remember his 25th death anniversary on November 4th, we reflect on the legacy he left behind after his untimely death from colon cancer. For a significant part of his career, Marshall was considered one of the fastest and most formidable bowlers in the world, helping to shape the West Indies into arguably the greatest Test team in cricket history.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual.

Andhra team joins Gandhians to protest against 'bulldozer action' in Varanasi

By Rosamma Thomas* November 1 marked the 52nd day of the 100-day relay fast at the satyagraha site of Rajghat in Varanasi, seeking the restoration of the 12 acres of land to the Sarva Seva Sangh, the Gandhian organization that was evicted from the banks of the river. Twelve buildings were demolished as the site was abruptly taken over by the government after “bulldozer” action in August 2023, even as the matter was pending in court.

Will Bangladesh go Egypt way, where military ruler is in power for a decade?

By Vijay Prashad* The day after former Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina left Dhaka, I was on the phone with a friend who had spent some time on the streets that day. He told me about the atmosphere in Dhaka, how people with little previous political experience had joined in the large protests alongside the students—who seemed to be leading the agitation. I asked him about the political infrastructure of the students and about their political orientation. He said that the protests seemed well-organized and that the students had escalated their demands from an end to certain quotas for government jobs to an end to the government of Sheikh Hasina. Even hours before she left the country, it did not seem that this would be the outcome.

Will Left victory in Sri Lanka deliver economic sovereignty plan, go beyond 'tired' IMF agenda?

By Atul Chandra, Vijay Prashad* On September 22, 2024, the Sri Lankan election authority announced that Anura Kumara Dissanayake of the Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP)-led National People’s Power (NPP) alliance won the presidential election. Dissanayake, who has been the leader of the left-wing JVP since 2014, defeated 37 other candidates, including the incumbent president Ranil Wickremesinghe of the United National Party (UNP) and his closest challenger Sajith Premadasa of the Samagi Jana Balawegaya.

Green Revolution’s reliance on chemical fertilizers, pesticides contributing to Punjab's health crisis

By Bharat Dogra, Jagmohan Singh* Punjab was once synonymous with robust health, particularly in its rural areas, where farmers were known for their strength and vitality. However, in recent years, reports from these villages tell a different story, with rising cases of serious health issues, including cancer. What led to this decline? The answer lies largely in the erosion of good nutrition, once a hallmark of Punjabi village life. The health of a population is closely tied to its nutrition, and Punjab's reputation as a provider of high-quality nutrition has suffered greatly. The loss of biodiversity in agriculture has led to a decrease in the variety and quality of crops, resulting in poorer nutrition. Pulses, a key source of protein, have seen a steep decline in cultivation due to the disruption of traditional farming practices by the Green Revolution. This has had a detrimental effect on both soil and human health. Although pulses are still available in the market, they are exp

Tributes paid to pioneer of Naxalism in Punjab, who 'dodged' police for 60 yrs

By Harsh Thakor* Jagjit Singh Sohal, known as Comrade Sharma, a pioneer of Naxalism in Punjab, passed away on October 20 at the age of 96. Committed to the Naxalite cause and a prominent Maoist leader, Sohal, who succeeded Charu Majumdar, played hide and seek with the police for almost six decades. He was cremated in Patiala.

Search This Blog