Skip to main content

Herbicide tolerant? Govt of India perpetrating 'falsehood' on Delhi varsity’s GM mustard

By Kavitha Kuruganti* 

After nearly 20 long years of hearings in a batch of petitions questioning India’s regulatory regime with regard to GMOs, the Supreme Court of India delivered a split verdict from a 2-judge Bench. The Bench refused to conclude whether Delhi University’s GM mustard is herbicide tolerant or not. The Coalition for a GM-Free India responded by asking the Government of India to begin implementing the common observations and conclusions of both the Hon’ble Judges on the Bench, even as other matters go to a larger Bench to be constituted by the Chief Justice of India. 
The Coalition pointed out that the Supreme Court has the 5-independent members’ Technical Expert Committee recommendations to guide it, since it is after all Court-appointed, consensus committee, where the Government’s two experts along with the petitioner-recommended experts gave a unanimous report on the Terms of Reference assigned to them. 
Concerned citizens and experts of India now await the constitution of the larger Bench and the next round of proceedings to begin. The Coalition welcomes the order that the government organise public consultations preferably within the next 4 months for a national policy to be formulated on the subject. The Coalition calls upon ordinary citizens, experts, farmers organisations, beekeepers, consumer rights and environmental groups and other stakeholders to participate in large numbers in the public consultations ordered by the Court, and also asked state governments to take the opportunity to present considered views keeping public interest foremost. 
The Coalition welcomed the observations and conclusions of Justice Nagarathna. Justice Nagarathna, the senior Judge on the Bench concluded that the processing of the application and approval of GM mustard was violative of Article 21, of the Precautionary Principle, of the doctrine of public trust and was ignoring the recommendations of the SC Technical Expert Committee etc. She concluded that GM mustard approval infringes on Inter-Generational Equity. She pointed out that the Expert Committee appointed in 2022 gave diametrically opposite views to that of another Committee and relied on foreign studies while dipping into scientific literature, as an illustration. 
While Justice Sanjay Karol did not find any manifest arbitrariness or capriciousness, or non-application of mind in GM mustard application processing, or anything unlawful about GEAC Rules and its functioning, he also stated in his conclusions that human health tests are required as part of risk assessment and decision-making, and sought independent studies to be conducted. 
He said that study reports need to be uploaded, and public participation in decision-making enabled. Justice Karol also commented on the need for state-of-the-art laboratories and other required infrastructure to be set up. The Bench concluded that judicial review of various regulatory decisions and the regime is permissible. 
The Coalition now calls upon the Government to implement those conclusions and directions that are common to both the judges’ verdicts. Apart from asking for a national policy to be created through widespread public consultations with adequate publicity and with the involvement of state governments, both the judges asked for statutory Rules to be created to mitigate conflict of interest. 
Human health tests are required as part of risk assessment and decision-making on GM mustard application processing
They also asked for all studies to be uploaded in the public domain, while the regulators have been refusing to do so despite earlier court orders to this effect. They asked for independent studies to be conducted, and talked about compliance to Sec.23 of Food Safety and Standards Act 2006.
The Coalition also condemned the falsehoods perpetrated by the Government of India in and outside the Court, to mask the fact that Delhi University’s GM mustard is a herbicide tolerant crop, and hoped that this matter would get addressed unambiguously in future proceedings.
The Coalition also asks all citizens of India and state governments to participate in the public consultations, to ensure that various matters of public interest are fully addressed by the Government of India in any policy that it formulates now on this subject including on:
  • Farmers’ seed sovereignty
  • Environmental sustainability and ecological security
  • Human health
  • Socio-Economic considerations like employment protection
  • India’s trade security
  • Consumer rights
  • Precautionary Principle and Inter-generational equity
  • State government’s constitutional authority over agriculture and health
  • Protection of organic and natural farming in the country, and local germplasm
  • Conservation of biodiversity
  • Scientific and rigorous regulation of new gene technologies like genome editing
  • Adherence to India’s commitments in the Cartagena Protocol which means a comprehensive statutory biosafety law, which ensures transparent, independent, scientific and accountable decision-making on all related aspects 
The Coalition asks the Government of India to make the consultations truly participatory, for deliberative democratic processes to shape the national policy, implementing this Order in letter and spirit.
---
*Coalition for a GM-Free India

Comments

TRENDING

70,000 migrants, sold on Canadian dream, face uncertain future: Canada reinvents the xenophobic wheel

By Saurav Sarkar*  Bikram Singh is running out of time on his post-study work visa in Canada. Singh is one of about 70,000 migrants who were sold on the Canadian dream of eventually making the country their home but now face an uncertain future with their work permits set to expire by December 2024. They came from places like India, China, and the Philippines, and sold their land and belongings in their home countries, took out loans, or made other enormous commitments to get themselves to Canada.

Kerala government data implicates the Covid vaccines for excess deaths

By Bhaskaran Raman*  On 03 Dec 2024, Mr Unnikrishnan of the Indian Express had written an article titled: “Kerala govt data busts vaccine death myth; no rise in mortality post-Covid”. It claims “no significant change in the death rate in the 35-44 age group between 2019 and 2023”. However, the claim is obviously wrong, even to a casual observer, as per the same data which the article presents, as explained below.

PM-JUGA: Support to states and gram sabhas for the FRA implementation and preparation and execution of CFR management plan

By Dr. Manohar Chauhan*  (Over the period, under 275(1), Ministry of Tribal Affairs has provided fund to the states for FRA implementation. Besides, some states like Odisha, Chhattisgarh and Maharashtra allocated special fund for FRA implementation. Now PM-JUDA under “Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan(DAJGUA) lunched by Prime Minister on 2nd October 2024 will not only be the major source of funding from MoTA to the States/UTs, but also will be the major support to the Gram sabha for the preparation and execution of CFR management Plan).

Defeat of martial law: Has the decisive moment for change come in South Korea?

By Steven Lee  Late at night on December 3, soldiers stormed into South Korea’s National Assembly in armored vehicles and combat helicopters. Assembly staff desperately blocked their assault with fire extinguishers and barricades. South Korea’s President Yoon Suk Yeol had just declared martial law to “ eliminate ‘anti-state’ forces .”

Operation Kagar represents Indian state's intensified attempt to extinguish Maoism: Resistance continues

By Harsh Thakor Operation Kagar represents the Indian state's intensified attempt to extinguish Maoism, which claims to embody the struggles and aspirations of Adivasis. Criminalized by the state, the Maoists have been portrayed as a threat, with Operation Kagar deploying strategies that jeopardize their activities. This operation weaves together economic, cultural, and political motives, allegedly with drone attacks on Adivasi homes.

How Amit Shah's statement on Ambedkar reflects frustration of those uncomfortable with Dalit assertion, empowerment

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  Dr. B.R. Ambedkar remains the liberator and emancipator of India’s oppressed communities. However, attempts to box him between two Brahmanical political parties betray a superficial and self-serving understanding of his legacy. The statement by Union Home Minister Amit Shah in the Rajya Sabha was highly objectionable, reflecting the frustration of those uncomfortable with Dalit assertion and empowerment.

Balod tech fest tests students’ interest in innovative ideas in the fields of science, engineering, start-ups

By Our Representative  A techno fest scheduled on December 20 and 21 in Balod district of Chhattisgarh will test the innovative ideas of school students in the fields of science, engineering and start-ups.  For this two-day fest organised at Maheswari Bhawan of the district, a total of 824 models made by students were initially registered. Out of those, a selection committee chose 200 models from several schools spread over five blocks of Balod. These will be on display on these two days from 10am to 4.30pm. Out of many ideas, one of the most interesting models is a smart glove which can be used by children with impairments and disabilities. For those who cannot speak at all or have speech difficulty, they can ask for help from caregivers by pressing their fingers on the glove after wearing it. This will attract attention. 

Local businessman subjected to physical assault, verbal abuse: Demand for accountability, justice

By Kirity Roy* On October 9, 2024, a disturbing incident of harassment and abuse took place in the Swarupnagar Block of North 24 Parganas district, involving a local businessman, Hasanur Gazi, who was subjected to physical assault, verbal abuse, and religious discrimination by a Border Security Force (BSF) constable. The incident, which occurred at the Hakimpur Checkpost, has raised serious concerns about the safety and dignity of citizens living in border areas, especially those belonging to religious minorities.

Affable but arrogant, embodying contradictions, Raj Kapoor's legacy will endure as long as Bollywood exists

By Harsh Thakor*  December 14 marks the birth centenary of Raj Kapoor, a filmmaker and visionary who revolutionized Bollywood, elevating it to new heights by exploring uncharted emotional and social territories. Kapoor wasn’t just a filmmaker; he was a storyteller who touched the souls of the masses and reflected the pulse of post-partition India with unparalleled depth. His films acted as a unifying force in a divided nation, transcending social and cultural boundaries.

Suspicious death of Dalit laborer in BSF custody: A call for justice

By Kirity Roy*  The tragic and suspicious death of Mr. Babai Barui, a Dalit daily wage laborer from North 24 Parganas, West Bengal, has raised serious concerns regarding custodial violence and the violation of fundamental rights. Mr. Barui, son of Sukharanjan Barui, resided in Pallishree Sangsad, Bongaon, and was arrested by the Border Security Force (BSF) on November 9, 2024, near the Angrail border on allegations of smuggling. The very next day, he was found dead under mysterious circumstances, with visible injuries that point toward possible custodial violence.