Desist from academic censorship, stop threatening scholars: Letter to ICMR

Counterview Desk
In a letter to the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) director, the Universal Health Organisation (UHO) which consists of prominent health experts, has insisted that the Government of India’s top medical research agency should lead high quality research on vaccine safety and “desist from academic censorship”.
Objecting to the ICMR asking the Journal of Drug Safety retract the peer-reviewed study by two Benaras Hindu University (BHU) scholars, UHO said, the study, in fact, has “filled an important gap in terms of field data analyzing the long-term safety of the widely administered Covid vaccine Covaxin.”
Insisting that the two authors of the study are being threatened, the letter, addressed to Dr Rajiv Bahl, said, “Privately addressed letters to the authors and the journal editor have been leaked to the press and in social media. This amounts to harassment and intimidation of the study authors. ICMR must investigate this transgression of professional conduct.”

Text:

A recent research study [link] was published on 13 May 2024 in the Journal of Drug Safety by a research group from IMS-BHU. This filled an important gap in terms of field data analyzing the long-term safety of the widely administered Covid vaccine Covaxin. While we were hoping and expecting a research institution of repute such as ICMR to build upon this study, address its shortcomings, and elevate the standards of vaccine safety, we are aghast to come across letters sent by ICMR (a) asking for the retraction of the paper, and (b) threatening the authors of the study. Several aspects are amiss in this context.

In its letters, ICMR has pointed out that the published study lacks a control group. This is indeed a shortcoming of the study – but is admitted in the study itself, in the “limitations” section. No scientific study is without limitations, and the study must be used to further improve vaccine safety studies. To the contrary, calling for its retraction is unbecoming of a scientific institution of ICMR’s stature.
While a study with a control group would certainly be of higher quality, this immediately points to the fact that it is researchers from ICMR who have access to the data with the control group, i.e. the original phase-3 trials of Covaxin – as well publicized in “The Vaccine War” movie. ICMR thus owes it to the people of India, that it publishes the long-term follow-up of phase-3 trials. It is to be noted that interim results [link] of the phase-3 trial, also cited by Dr. Priya Abraham in “The Vaccine War” movie, had a mere 56 days of safety follow-up, much shorter than the one-year follow-up in the IMS-BHU study. Furthermore the ICMR phase-3 trial study did not include adolescents below 18 years, which the IMS-BHU study does. While Bharat Biotech has claimed in the media [link] that “safety monitoring was continued”, neither Bharat Biotech nor ICMR has published the long-term safety results.
In Sep 2022, Bharat Biotech, the manufacturer of Covaxin, had published a study on Covaxin for ages 2-18 [link]. This study too lacked a control group. Furthermore, it had a mere 175 adolescents in the 12-18 age-group, likely around just 80-90 in the 15-18 age-group, and it too had only 56 days of follow-up. In comparison, the IMS-BHU study has 635 adolescents in the 15-18 age-group followed-up for a year. These aspects further underscore the intrinsic value of the IMS-BHU study despite its stated limitations.
Privately addressed letters to the authors and the journal editor have been leaked to the press and in social media. This amounts to harassment and intimidation of the study authors. ICMR must investigate this transgression of professional conduct.
The letter addressed to the authors is spreading a falsehood about the first author Dr. Upinder Kaur. Dr. Kaur has not acknowledged ICMR at all. While “The Vaccine War” movie is celebrating women scientists, this ICMR letter is spreading a falsehood about a woman researcher. ICMR must thus issue a note of apology in this regard to Dr. Kaur.
On the issue of use of telephonic interview for safety follow-up, it is certainly a limitation, as also admitted by the authors in the “limitations” section. However, it is to be noted that the same research group also published a safety follow-up study on Covishield in Jul 2021 [link]. This study was later cited by a study on Covishield with several authors from ICMR [link], including the then director Dr. Balram Bhargava. Therefore, ICMR researchers acknowledged then that telephonic interview is a valid process, although not most desirable. Furthermore, telephonic interviews for follow-up is part of ICMR’s own Covaxin rollout plan [link]. Thus, citing telephonic interviews as a reason to call for retraction of the IMS-BHU study is unsound and inconsistent.
The issue of author acknowledgement itself has been blown out of proportion. If ICMR does not wish to be acknowledged, it can communicate this privately to the authors and the editor and an erratum can be issued – a routine matter in scientific publications.
The above appears all the more stark in light of the following. On 29 Aug 2022, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India had issued a notice [link] to ICMR, in the case of “Rachana Gangu & ANR vs Union of India & ORS”, involving Covid vaccine safety. However, even after nearly 21 months, ICMR has not found time to respond to this notice, while it has found time within a few days to raise issue with author acknowledgement in a publication. ICMR must invert its priorities and give more weightage to the notice from the Indian Supreme Court.

In summary, we reiterate that ICMR must lead the country in giving vaccine safety its due priority. It must publish data from the original phase-3 trial with long-term follow-up, as well as lead other high quality research studies on long-term safety. It must certainly desist from academic censorship of the already small number of studies on Covaxin long-term safety. ICMR owes this to the lakhs of Indian children to whom Covaxin has been administered, for these children have their entire life ahead of them.
In anticipation of a positive response,
Yours Sincerely,
Managing Committee of Universal Health Organisation (UHO) – https://uho.org.in/
Dr. Amitav Banerjee, MD, Clinical Epidemiologist, Pune
Dr. Arvind Singh Kushwaha, Community Medicine, Auraiya
Dr. Veena Raghava, MBBS, DA, Clinical Nutrition (NIN), Bengaluru
Dr. Praveen K Saxena, MBBS, DMRD, FCMT, Hyderabad
Dr. Maya Valecha, MD, DGO, Vadodara
Dr. Gayatri Panditrao, BHMS (Homoeopathic Consultant), PGDEMS, Pune
Mr. Ashutosh Pathak, Journalist, QVIVE, Delhi
Mr. Prakash Pohare, Journalist, Deshonnati, Akola
Prof. Bhaskaran Raman, Professor of Computer Science and Engineering, Mumbai

Comments

Beyond his riding skill, Karl Umrigar was admired for his radiance, sportsmanship, and affability

By Harsh Thakor* Karl Umrigar's name remains etched in the annals of Indian horse racing, a testament to a talent tragically cut short. An accident on the racetrack at the tender age of nineteen robbed India of a rider on the cusp of greatness. Had he survived, there's little doubt he would have ascended to international stature, possibly becoming the greatest Indian jockey ever. Even 46 years after his death, his name shines brightly, reminiscent of an inextinguishable star. His cousin, Pesi Shroff, himself blossomed into one of the most celebrated jockeys in Indian horse racing.

Aurangzeb’s last will recorded by his Maulvi: Allah shouldn't make anyone emperor

By Mohan Guruswamy Aurangzeb’s grave is a simple slab open to the sky lying along the roadside at Khuldabad near Aurangabad. I once stopped by to marvel at the tomb of an Emperor of India whose empire was as large as Ashoka the Great's. It was only post 1857 when Victoria's domain exceeded this. The epitaph reads: "Az tila o nuqreh gar saazand gumbad aghniyaa! Bar mazaar e ghareebaan gumbad e gardun bas ast." (The rich may well construct domes of gold and silver on their graves. For the poor folks like me, the sky is enough to shelter my grave) The modest tomb of Aurangzeb is perhaps the least recognised legacies of the Mughal Emperor who ruled the land for fifty eventful years. He was not a builder having expended his long tenure in war and conquest. Towards the end of his reign and life, he realised the futility of it all. He wrote: "Allah should not make anyone an emperor. The most unfortunate person is he who becomes one." Aurangzeb’s last will was re...

PUCL files complaint with SC against Gujarat police, municipal authorities for 'unlawful' demolitions, custodial 'violence'

By A Representative The People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) has lodged a formal complaint with the Chief Justice of India, urging the Supreme Court to initiate suo-moto contempt proceedings against the police and municipal authorities in Ahmedabad, Gujarat. The complaint alleges that these officials have engaged in unlawful demolitions and custodial violence, in direct violation of a Supreme Court order issued in November 2024.

How the slogan Jai Bhim gained momentum as movement of popularity and revolution

By Dr Kapilendra Das* India is an incomprehensible plural country loaded with diversities of religions, castes, cultures, languages, dialects, tribes, societies, costumes, etc. The Indians have good manners/etiquette (decent social conduct, gesture, courtesy, politeness) that build healthy relationships and take them ahead to life. In many parts of India, in many situations, and on formal occasions, it is common for people of India to express and exchange respect, greetings, and salutation for which we people usually use words and phrases like- Namaskar, Namaste, Pranam, Ram Ram, Jai Ram ji, Jai Sriram, Good morning, shubha sakal, Radhe Radhe, Jai Bajarangabali, Jai Gopal, Jai Jai, Supravat, Good night, Shuvaratri, Jai Bhole, Salaam walekam, Walekam salaam, Radhaswami, Namo Buddhaya, Jai Bhim, Hello, and so on. A soft attitude always creates strong relationships. A relationship should not depend only on spoken words. They should rely on understanding the unspoken feeling too. So w...

राजस्थान, मध्यप्रदेश, पश्चिम बंगाल, झारखंड और केरल फिसड्डी: जल जीवन मिशन के लक्ष्य को पाने समन्वित प्रयास जरूरी

- राज कुमार सिन्हा* जल संसाधन से जुड़ी स्थायी समिति ने वर्तमान लोकसभा सत्र में पेश रिपोर्ट में बताया है कि "नल से जल" मिशन में राजस्थान, मध्यप्रदेश, पश्चिम बंगाल, झारखंड और केरल फिसड्डी साबित हुए हैं। जबकि देश के 11 राज्यों में शत-प्रतिशत ग्रामीणों को नल से जल आपूर्ति शुरू कर दी गई है। रिपोर्ट में समिति ने केंद्र सरकार को सिफारिश की है कि मिशन पुरा करने में राज्य सरकारों की समस्याओं पर गौर किया जाए।

Incarcerated for 2,424 days, Sudhir Dhawale combines Ambedkarism with Marxism

By Harsh Thakor One of those who faced incarceration both under Congress and BJP rule, Sudhir Dhawale was arrested on June 6, 2018, one of the first six among the 16 people held in what became known as the Elgar Parishad case. After spending 2,424 days in incarceration, he became the ninth to be released from jail—alongside Rona Wilson, who walked free with him on January 24. The Bombay High Court granted them bail, citing the prolonged imprisonment without trial as a key factor. I will always remember the moments we spent together in Mumbai between 1998 and 2006, during public meetings and protests across a wide range of issues. Sudhir was unwavering in his commitment to Maoism, upholding the torch of B.R. Ambedkar, and resisting Brahmanical fascism. He sought to bridge the philosophies of Marxism and Ambedkarism. With boundless energy, he waved the banner of liberation, becoming the backbone of the revolutionary democratic centre in Mumbai and Maharashtra. He dedicated himself ...

State Human Rights Commission directs authorities to uphold environmental rights in Vadodara's Vishwamitri River Project

By A Representative The Gujarat State Human Rights Commission (GSHRC) has ordered state and Vadodara municipal authorities to strictly comply with environmental and human rights safeguards during the Vishwamitri River Rejuvenation Project, stressing that the river’s degradation disproportionately affects marginalized communities and violates citizens’ rights to a healthy environment. The Commission mandated an immediate halt to ecologically destructive practices, rehabilitation of affected communities, transparent adherence to National Green Tribunal (NGT) orders, and public consultations with experts and residents. The order follows the Concerned Citizens of Vadodara coalition—environmentalists, ecologists, and urban planners—submitting a detailed letter to authorities, amplifying calls for accountability. The group warned that current plans to “re-section” and “desilt” the river contradict the NGT’s 2021 Vishwamitri River Action Plan, which prioritizes floodpla...

CPM’s evaluation of BJP reflects its political character and its reluctance to take on battle against neo-fascism

By Harsh Thakor* A controversial debate has emerged in the revolutionary camp regarding the Communist Party of India (Marxist)'s categorization of the Bharatiya Janata Party. Many Communists criticize the CPM’s reluctance to label the BJP as a fascist party and India as a fascist state. Various factors must be considered to arrive at an accurate assessment. Understanding the original meaning and historical development of fascism is essential, as well as analyzing how it manifests in the present global and national context.

Implications of deaths of Maoist leaders G. Renuka and Ankeshwarapu Sarayya in Chhattisgarh

By Harsh Thakor* In the wake of recent security operations in southern Chhattisgarh, two senior Maoist leaders, G. Renuka and Ankeshwarapu Sarayya, were killed. These operations, which took place amidst a historically significant Maoist presence, resulted in the deaths of 31 individuals on March 20th and 16 more three days prior.

Haven't done a good deed, inner soul is cursing me as sinner: Aurangzeb's last 'will'

Counterview Desk The Tomb of Aurangzeb, the last of the strong Mughal emperors, located in Khuldabad, Aurangabad district, Maharashtra, has this epitaph inscribed on it: "Az tila o nuqreh gar saazand gumbad aghniyaa! Bar mazaar e maa ghareebaan gumbad e gardun bas ast" (the rich may well construct domes of gold and silver on their graves. For the poor folks like me, the sky is enough to shelter my grave).

Search This Blog